Primary Objective: To show that an integrated chronic care program in a specialized AF clinic reduces cardiovascular hospitalizations and mortality.Secondary Objective(s): 1) To demonstrate the benefits of an integrated chronic care program in terms…
ID
Source
Brief title
Condition
- Cardiac arrhythmias
- Embolism and thrombosis
Synonym
Research involving
Sponsors and support
Intervention
Outcome measures
Primary outcome
The primary endpoint is a composite, defined as unplanned admission to the
hospital for any cardiovascular reason and cardiovascular death.
The endpoint events leading to unplanned hospitalisation or death are
therefore:
1. Left or right ventricular heart failure which is independent of LVEF
(preferably confirmed by biomarker assessment using NT-pro-BNP) and requiring
intravenous diuretics or an unplanned hospitalisation without admission when
any adjustment of heart failure therapy suffices;
2. Ischemic thromboembolic complications including stroke (the sudden onset of
a focal neurologic deficit in a location consistent with the territory of a
major cerebral artery caused by an arterial thrombus in this artery,
categorized as ischemic stroke and TIA (transient stroke, whereby clinical
symptoms disappear within 24 hours))confirmed by a neurologist on the basis of
computerised tomography or MRI; peripheral emboli, pulmonary emboli or systemic
emboli (an acute vascular occlusion of an extremity or organ) documented by
means of imaging, surgery or autopsy;
3. Acute coronary syndrome (STEMI/ NSTEMI/ unstable angina pectoris, with at
least two of the following characteristics: (1) typical chest pain for at least
20 minutes; (2) ischemic electrocardiographic changes, and (3) cardiac enzyme
elevation more than twice the upper limit of normal or instable angina
pectoris, respectively documented on ECG as well as/ or only in blood levels of
key chemical markers);
4. Major bleeding(an acute bleeding with the hemoglobin value decreased by > 20
g/ L (>2g/ dL; 1,2 mmol/l), or requiring blood transfusion of at least two
units of blood, or a symptomatic bleeding in a critical organ or area
(intra-cranial (intracerebral hemorrhage, subdural hemorrhage or subarachnoid
hemorrhage), retroperitoneal, spinal, ocular, pericardial, or a traumatic
articular) or fatal bleeding;
5. Arrhythmic or potential arrhythmic events (atrial fibrillation, -flutter,
other supraventricular rhythm or sustained ventricular tachycardia confirmed by
ECG, > 30 sec), syncope (a sudden temporary loss of consciousness associated
with a loss of postural tone with spontaneous recovery not requiring electrical
or chemical cardioversion) or cardiac arrest (circulatory arrest necessitating
resuscitation and hospitalisation) or an unplanned hospitalisation without
admission with any adjustment required to rate or rhythm control therapy, and
6. Life-threatening adverse effects of rate or rhythm controlling drugs (any
pro-arrhythmia of Vaughan Williams classes I and III anti-arrhythmic drugs,
digitalis intoxication, drug-induced heart failure or conduction disturbances
required hospitalisation);
Cardiovascular deaths were classified according to a modified Hinkle and Thaler
classification (Hinkle et al., 1982).
Cardiovascular mortality
Death from a diagnosed cardiovascular cause, classified as cardiac arrhythmic,
cardiac non-arrhythmic, or a vascular non-cardiac cause.
Cardiac, arrhythmic
Death from rapid ventricular tachycardia or fibrillation and had this rhythm
not occurred the patient would have probably survived for at least 4 months.
Loss of cardiac output and pulse is sudden and precedes collapse of the
circulation (defined as a state of very low cardiac output, poor peripheral
perfusion, systolic blood pressure of less than 80 mm Hg, or dependence on
intravenous inotropic support) or severe pulmonary oedema, characterised by
severe respiratory distress of sudden onset without evidence of non-cardiac
cause. The patient is not already in shock or pulmonary oedema at the time of
onset of the arrhythmia.
Cardiac, non-arrhythmic
The patient develops collapse of the circulation or is in shock or severe
pulmonary oedema before loss of cardiac output and fatal arrhythmia. Special
categories included monitored patients who had profound bradycardia or
asystole, or a rhythm generally compatible with normal cardiac output, and,
therefore, probably electromechanical dissociation, immediately before abrupt
circulatory collapse.
Vascular, non-cardiac
For example, aortic dissection, ruptured aneurysm, other haemorrhage, cerebral
vascular accident, pulmonary embolus.
Definitions for the components of the primary endpoint
Cardiovascular mortality
Death from a diagnosed cardiovascular cause, classified as cardiac arrhythmic,
cardiac non-arrhythmic, or a vascular non-cardiac cause.
Heart failure
Heart failure independent of LVEF (preferably confirmed by biomarker assessment
using NT-pro-BNP) necessitating hospitalisation and requiring intravenous
diuretics, or other adjustments of heart failure therapy during hospitalisation.
Stroke
A disabling hemorrhagic, ischemic, or undetermined stroke confirmed by a
neurologist on the basis of computerised tomography or magnetic resonance
imaging and necessitating hospitalisation.
Systemic emboli
An acute arterial occlusion of an extremity or organ. Have to be confirmed by a
physician, typically with some type of imaging and necessitating
hospitalization.
Acute coronary syndrome
STEMI/ NSTEMI Myocardial infarction with at least 2 of the following: (1)
typical chest pain for at least 20 minutes; (2) electrocardiogram showing
changes of acute myocardial infarction; and (3) cardiac enzyme elevation more
than twice the upper limit of normal or instable angina pectoris, respectively
documented on ECG as well as/or only in blood levels of key chemical markers,
necessitating hospitalisation.
Bleeding
A bleeding with the hemoglobin value decreased by > 20 g/ L (>2g/ dL) or
requiring blood transfusion or symptomatic bleeding in a critical organ or area
(intra-cranial, retroperitoneal, spinal, ocular, pericardial, or a traumatic
articular) or fatal.
Arrhythmic events
Includes episodes of atrial fibrillation and syncope, necessitating
hospitalisation, or adjustments in rate- or rhythm control therapy during
hospitalisation.
Syncope
A sudden temporary loss of consciousness associated with a loss of postural
tone with spontaneous recovery not requiring electrical or chemical
cardioversion.
Sustained ventricular tachycardia
Lasting more than 30 seconds and must be documented on electrocardiogram (ECG)
and requires hospitalization.
Cardiac arrest
Circulatory arrest necessitating resuscitation and hospitalization.
Life-threatening adverse effects of rate or rhythm controlling drugs
Pro-arrhythmia of classes I and III anti-arrhythmic drugs, digitalis
intoxication, drug-induced heart failure or conduction disturbances and
ventricular arrhythmias necessitating hospitalisation.
Secondary outcome
The secondary endpoints are:
1. The cost benefit of the intervention by means of a cost effectiveness
analysis;
2. The extent to which the comprehensive cardiovascular treatment is in
accordance to the latest ESC guidelines for AF, HF guidelines
of acute and chronic heart failure and CVD Prevention guidelines;
3. Patient quality of life and satisfaction;
4. Patient anxiety and/ or depression;
5. Patients* knowledge of AF and
6. Patients* compliance in medication.
Background summary
The treatment of patients with atrial fibrillation is often inadequate due to
bad adherence to the guidelines.
Especially the poor guideline adherence in relation to the use of
antithrombotic therapy is leading to increased morbidity and mortality in
patients with atrial fibrillation.
In order to improve outcomes for patients with AF, an integrated chronic care
program (ICCP) for patients with AF was developed in the Maastricht University
Medical Center. The program consists of a nurse-driven, guideline-based,
software-supported ICCP for patients with atrial fibrillation in the outpatient
specialized AF Clinic. Effects of the program were compared with routine
cardiac care for patients with newly diagnosed AF in a large outcomes study
with 712 patients.
The combined endpoint of cardiovascular hospitalization and cardiovascular
death showed a relative risk reduction of 35% by nurse-led care (14,3% nurse
led care compared to 20,8% usual care, hazard ratio 0,65; 95% CI, 0,45 to 0,93;
p<0,05). The adherence to guideline recommendations was significantly better in
the nurse-led care group. This ICCP for patients with AF represents the
combined beneficial effect of the disease management system in a single centre
trial.
In addition to these outcomes a multicenter trial is needed to study if the
results are generalizable to other hospitals where an Integrated Chronic Care
Program at a specialized AF clinic is implemented.
It is hypothesized that treatment at a specialized AF clinic is superior to
usual care in terms of cardiovascular mortality, cardiovascular
hospitalizations and cost effectiveness.
Study objective
Primary Objective:
To show that an integrated chronic care program in a specialized AF clinic
reduces cardiovascular hospitalizations and mortality.
Secondary Objective(s):
1) To demonstrate the benefits of an integrated chronic care program in terms
of cost effectiveness expressed in quality adjusted life years (Qualy*s). 2) To
demonstrate process outcomes in terms of guideline adherence and
comprehensiveness of cardiovascular treatment: the extent to which treatment is
delivered according to the latest ESC AF guidelines and modified for the
Netherlands, the HF guidelines of acute and chronic heart failure and the CVD
Prevention guidelines; 3) To demonstrate that an integrated chronic care
program in a specialized AF clinic improves quality of life (including anxiety
and depression) and patient satisfaction; 4) To demonstrate that patient
knowledge improves significantly better in the intervention group and by that
reduces hospitalizations and cardiovascular mortality; 5) To show that patient
compliance in medication improves significantly using personal electronic
guidance through Medical manager* (developed by R. Pisters, MUMC) in the
intervention group.
Study design
The RACE4 is an event driven study. A total number of 246 events is needed. The
study is divided in two arms: a control arm (usual care provided by the
cardiologist) and an intervention arm (integrated chronic care program at a
specialized AF clinic) in 8 hospitals in the Netherlands. In total 1716
patients with newly diagnosed AF will be included. The total duration of the
study is 6,5 years. The inclusion of patients will start at the 1st of December
2012. The foreseen recruitment period concedes till june 2018 and follow-up
till June 2019. Data will be collected at inclusion, after 3 months, 6 months,
12 months and every year thereafter. Patients in the intervention group will be
seen at 3 months after the first appointment at the AFclinic, will get a
phonecall at 6 months and thereafter annually monitoring at the AF clinic.
Control at the cardiologist will be planned advised by the cardiologist.
Intervention
The intervention in this study contains the treatment through an integrated
chronic care program at the specialized AF clinic. The ICCP consists of a nurse
specialist, cardiologist, guidelines-based software supported program,
web-based patient centered management of patient*s own medication and tailored
telemonitoring at an outpatient AF clinic.
Study burden and risks
Patients in the control group and intervention group will not have any risk or
burden for participation in the study. Patients in the control group will
receive care as usual and patients in the intervention group will receive care
through an integrated chronic care program for AF. Data of the pilot study at
the University Hospital of Maastricht with 712 patients, presented at the ACC
2011, showed a relative risk reduction of 35% in the combined endpoint of
cardiovascular hospitalization and cardiovascular death with patients at the
specialized AF clinic compared to the usual care at the cardiologist. The
adherence to the AF guideline recommendations was significantly better at the
AF clinic.
The study group is not aware of any potential risk or burden for the patient in
the intervention group (specialized AF clinic). The pilot suggests that the
ICCP at the specialized AF clinic will improve patient treatment and a risk
reduction in cardiovascular hospitalization and death.
P. Debyelaan 25
Maastricht 6202 AZ
NL
P. Debyelaan 25
Maastricht 6202 AZ
NL
Listed location countries
Age
Inclusion criteria
1. Patients with newly diagnosed AF detected on electrocardiogram (ECG), holter recordings
or eventrecorder with a duration > 30 seconds, 3 months before inclusion;
2. Patients with a history of diagnosed AF, with no regular control at a cardiologist for AF in the last
2 years and referred by a non-cardiologic medical specialist for new diagnostics or therapeutic issue;
3. Age * 18 years.
Exclusion criteria
1. No electrocardiographic objectified AF;
2. Unstable heart failure defined as NYHA IV or heart failure necessitating hospital admission < 3 months before inclusion;
3. Acute coronary syndrome (acute myocardial infarction or instable angina pectoris, with two of the following characteristics: chest pain and/ or ischemic electrocardiographic changes, and/ or cardiac enzyme rise) < 3 months before inclusion;
4. Untreated hyperthyroidism or < 3 months euthyroidism before inclusion;
5. Foreseen pacemaker, internal cardioverter defibrillator (ICD), and/ or cardiac resynchronization therapy (CRT);
6. Cardiac surgery * 3 months before inclusion;
7. Planned cardiac surgery;
8. Regular control and treatment, also for AF, at another specialized outpatient cardiac clinic;
9. Patient is not able to fill in the questionnaires;
10. Participation in other clinical study.
Design
Recruitment
Followed up by the following (possibly more current) registration
No registrations found.
Other (possibly less up-to-date) registrations in this register
No registrations found.
In other registers
Register | ID |
---|---|
ClinicalTrials.gov | NCT01740037 |
CCMO | NL39000.068.11 |