Investigating the effect of a 16 week multidisciplinary lifestyle programme, based on (1) a whole foods plant based diet (WFPD), (2) exercise and (3) stress management on:- disease activity (DAS28) for patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA), in…
ID
Source
Brief title
Condition
- Other condition
- Autoimmune disorders
Synonym
Health condition
gewrichtsaandoeningen & metabool syndroom
Research involving
Sponsors and support
Intervention
Outcome measures
Primary outcome
Rheumatoid arthritis:
Main endpoint for RA-patients is the difference between mean change in DAS28
scores from 0-16 weeks (measured blind by a research nurse) in the intervention
and control groups.
Arthralgia:
Main endpoint for the ACPA positive arthralgia-patients is the difference
between mean change in RA-risk scores from 0-16 weeks (measured blind by a
research nurse) in the intervention and control groups.
Osteoarthritis & metabolic syndrome:
Main endpoint for patients with OA & MetS is the difference between the mean
change in WOMAC scores from 0-16 weeks in the intervention and control groups.
Two-year extension study:
Main endpoint for the 2-year extension study (all groups) is the change in
adherence from 0-24 months, based on a variation of the 'Lifestyle Index
Adherence Score' as developed by Dean Ornish:
[t + ([u / 6 + v / 60] / 2) + ([x / 5 + y / 150] / 2) + z]/4
t = attendance meetings (index, e.g. 0.2 when attended 1 of 2 meetings)
u = stress reduction activities days per week
v = stress reduction activities minutes per week
x = exercise days per week
y = exercise minutes per week
z = adherence to diet
In which z is defined as:
[(grams of fibre per 1000 kilocalories/14) + (10/energypercentage saturated
fatty acids)]/2
Secondary outcome
Parameters are equal for all patients (RA, arthralgia and OA & MetS) unless
otherwise specified.
General:
- Self-reported physical (fatigue, pain intensity, pain interference, physical
function, sleep disturbance), mental (anxiety, depression) and social (ability
to participate in social roles & activities) health using the validated
Dutch-Flemish PROMIS®, which only needs 3-7 questions per domain to obtain
valid outcomes, quality of life and costs.
Body composition:
- Body weight (kg)
- Body height (cm)
- BMI (kg/m2)
- Waist circumference (cm, at approximate midpoint between the lower margin of
the last palpable rib and the top of the iliac crest).
- Total fat free mass (DEXA, kg & % of body weight)
- Total muscle mass (DEXA, kg & % of body weight)
- Total fat mass (DEXA, kg & % of body weight)
- 50% of all subjects in the RA and OA intervention groups (20 RA patients, 20
OA patients) as well as 5 RA and 5 OA patients in the control groups will be
recruited for MRI examination of (1) visceral adipose tissue (VAT)
(spectroscopy will be used to identify fatty acid distribution), (2)liver fat
content (spectroscopy will be used to identify fatty acid distribution) and (3)
intramuscular fat mass in the thigh muscle.
Physical performance:
- Hand grip strength (kg/force)
- Function (get-up-and-go test, seconds)
- Physical activity level (PAL, as coefficient related to base metabolic rate
[BMR]), measured with an activity tracker
Metabolic:
- Blood pressure
- Heart rate variability, measured by a 5-minute ECG
- Lipid profile (LDL, HDL, triglycerides in blood)
- Fasting Glucose (blood)
- HbA1c (blood)
Disease activity:
- Rheumatoid factor (RF, ACPA positive arthralgia patients for all
measurements, RA patients only at baseline and at the end of the one-year
extension study, blood)
- Anti-citrullinated Protein Antibodies (ACPA, ACPA positive arthralgia
patients for all measurements, RA patients only at baseline and at the end of
the one-year extension study, blood)
- Dominance of B-cell receptor clones (ACPA positive arthralgia at baseline, 4
months and at the end of the extension year)
- Erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR, component of DAS28)
- Inflammation in the knee (MRI, categorization)
- Gut microbiota composition (feces, colony forming units [CFU]/g) collected by
the subject at home, using an in-house kit to collect, freeze and transport the
faeces to Reade
- Saliva microbiota composition (saliva, CFU/g) collected by the subject at
home, using an in-house kit to collect, freeze and transport the saliva to Reade
- Metabolome change (blood and urine, percentage change from baseline)
Background summary
Although life expectancy has increased, people are also suffering from chronic
diseases for longer. Environmental factors play an important role in the
development of these diseases, as only a small part can be explained by genetic
factors. Unhealthy diets, obesity, physical inactivity, stress and smoking are
associated with a higher risk of rheumatoid arthritis (RA), while obesity and
metabolic syndrome (MetS) are associated with a higher risk of and progression
of osteoarthritis. Chronic low grade inflammation is often present in people
with unhealthy diets, lack of exercise and stress and can be an important
factor in the pathogenesis of chronic inflammatory diseases.
The current non-surgical treatment of RA and osteoarthritis consists mainly of
medication, exercise therapy and (for osteoarthritis) sometimes weight loss due
to a low-calorie diet or bariatric surgery. For many chronic diseases,
especially those related to MetS, lifestyle factors have been studied and in
some cases applied as therapy. The combination of different types of therapies
has demonstrated synergy effects. The Ornish Lifestyle Program for
Cardiovascular Diseases, based on full-fledged vegetable nutrition, exercise
and stress management, is a good example of an effective multidisciplinary
approach that is now widely offered and reimbursed by almost all US health
insurers.
A full-fledged vegetable diet has produced promising results for the treatment
of both RA and osteoarthritis, but has not yet been combined with other
lifestyle interventions. Although the application of good medication has helped
patients with RA considerably, 30% of patients do not respond to these drugs
and 69% of RA patients still suffer from pain, fatigue and reduced mobility. In
both RA and osteoarthritis there is a need for more evidence for treatments
focused on nutrition, exercise and mental health and in particular for
multidisciplinary interventions. This need is also relevant, as almost 2
million Dutch people suffer from some form of rheumatism. Healthcare costs
amount to almost ¤2 billion per year. If the costs of absenteeism due to
illness are also included, the total for RA and atrose together amounts to 20
billion euros per year, which is 3% of the Dutch gross domestic product.
Study objective
Investigating the effect of a 16 week multidisciplinary lifestyle programme,
based on (1) a whole foods plant based diet (WFPD), (2) exercise and (3) stress
management on:
- disease activity (DAS28) for patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA), in
comparison with usual care,
- the RA-risk score (Amsterdam risk rule score) in patients with ACPA-positive
arthralgia, in comparison with usual care and
- the WOMAC-score for patients with osteoarthritis (OA) and metabolic syndrome
(MetS), in comparison with usual care.
The primary objective of the 2-year extension study is to investigate adherence
to the programme components (diet, exercise and stress management) and to
perform a standardized reduction of medication in case of (near) remission.
The aforementioned objectives (primary objectives of the RCT) for patients with
RA, OA and arthralgia will be included as secondary objectives during the
2-year extension study.
Study design
In a 16-week randomized single-blind controlled trial, patients with
1. rheumatoid arthritis (RA) with a low to moderate disease
activity(2.6=2. ACPA positive arthralgia (pilot study, n=16) and
3. OA & MetS (n=80)
will either receive standard care or a multidisciplinary lifestyle
intervention, based on a WFPD, exercise and stress management.
At baseline, halfway and after 16 weeks primary outcomes DAS28, RA-risk score
and WOMAC-score will be measured for RA-, ACPA positive arthralgia- and OA
patients respectively. The control groups will be placed on a waiting list to
receive the intervention after the RCT.
After completion of the RCT, all patients (n=176) who participated in the
lifestyle intervention will be followed in a two-year extension program to
investigate adherence and to perform a standardized reduction of medication in
case of (near) remission.
Intervention
After screening and baseline measurements (RA patients will also visit a nurse
to determine the DAS28 score), patients are randomized. Those in the
intervention group start with individual intake meetings with a registered
dietician and a physiotherapist at baseline to determine personal objectives
and abilities and limitations regarding physical exercises.
During the 16-week program subjects will meet 10 times in groups of max 15
people. During all meetings (2- 3 hours) subjects will receive theoretical
and/or practical training, based on protocols tested in previous studies on the
following subjects:
1. Whole foods plant based
2. Exercise
3. Stress management
Subjects will be facilitated for their diet by means of fully elaborated week
plans, cooking class and they will receive a small box with supplements and
some specific plant-based products (e.g. condiments like miso and nutritional
yeast as well as *cream* substitutes) to get introduced in a new way of
cooking. Week plans are in line with recommended daily allowances of all
relevant macro- and micro nutrients. Subjects will also receive supplementation
(vitamin B12 and vitamin D according to dietary guidelines for vegan diets).
For exercise, subjects will be introduced to different forms of moderately
intense exercise and are motivated to integrate exercise in daily activities.
For stress management, subjects will receive psycho-education on the effects of
stress on health and stress management, as well as guided practice and home
exercises on relaxation techniques, breathing and visualization exercises and
coaching on sleep.
Medication is preferably not changed during the 16-week investigation period.
Patients with medication for diabetes and/or hypertension are instructed to
contact their general practitioner to discuss lowering of medication when
necessary. Patients are invited to report changes in medication as soon as
possible to the investigators. During the two-year extension period patients in
remission and their rheumatologists will taper medication according to a
standardized scheme.
The control group will receive usual care as delivered by their physician.
Study burden and risks
Burden:
- All meetings take place at Reade (due to COVID-19 measures now mainly online)
and two visits to the Amsterdam UMC (location Meibergdreef) for the
participants who undergo an MRI.
- Recruitment is targeted at motivated patients who are prepared to participate
in 10 group meetings and 5 to 7 individual visits.
- In addition to the group meetings, participants are inveted to visit for: (1)
baseline: intake interviews and baseline measurements (see below), (2)
measurements after 8 weeks and (3) end measurements. During the extension study
2 more measurements take place and the control group has 2 extra measuring
moments.
- 50 participants (randomly selected) will be asked to undergo an MRI
(Amsterdam UMC), subjects will be asked an extra consent to be invited for the
MRI.
- Intake dietician and physiotherapist: 60-90 minutes, this takes place on the
same day as the baseline measurements.
- Measurements: blood sampling (fasting, per measurement < 50 ml), blood
pressure and heart rate variability (5 minute ECG), DEXA scan, DAS28 (nurse, RA
only), anthropometry, indirect calorimetry, some physical tests (walking test,
get-up-and-go test) and some questionnaires (PROMIS®, which significantly
shortens the number of questions to be answered).
- Participants receive a letter from Reade for their employer/health & safety
service in which Reade proposes to exempt the employee from work for a few
hours per week during the trial (this point was included in consultation with
the 'ambassadors', 11 patients involved in the development of the program,
including an industrial doctor).
Risks:
Given the nature of the intervention, there are few risks, since the trial
concerns healthy behaviour. Subjects are motivated patients who may see the
intervention as an opportunity rather than a burden. The program may be
experienced as difficult or tough. Therefore, dropouts have to be taken into
account, estimated at 20%.
Dr. Jan van Breemenstraat 2
Amsterdam 1056 AB
NL
Dr. Jan van Breemenstraat 2
Amsterdam 1056 AB
NL
Listed location countries
Age
Inclusion criteria
- Patients => 18 years.
- RA with low to moderate disease activity (2.6=EULAR recommendations for use in clinical practice.
- Unchanged disease modifying anti rheumatic drug (DMARD) treatment (including
unchanged dose) for at least 3 months or non-use of DMARDs, if applicable.,
ACPA positive arthralgia:
- Patients => 18 years.
- (History of) arthralgia.
- Seropositive for ACPA.
- No history of arthritis documented by a rheumatologist., Osteoarthritis &
metabolic syndrome:
- OA in hip and/or knee, diagnosed according to the criteria or the American
College of Rheumatology (without age-criterion).
- Metabolic syndrome according to the criteria defined by the National
Cholesterol Education Program (NCEP) Adult Treatment Panel III (ATP III): when
3 or more of the following criteria are met: waist circumference >=102 (*) / >=88
(*) cm, fasting glucose >=6.1 mmol/l, triglycerides >=1.7 mmol/l, HDL <1.04 (*) /
<1.29 (*) mmol/l, blood pressure >=130/85 mmHg.
Exclusion criteria
- Already following a (near-)vegan diet.
- Pregnancy.
- Absolute contra-indication for exercise therapy: resting systolic blood
pressure of >200 mmHg or diastolic blood pressure of >115 mmHg, acute
myocardial infarction within the last 3 months, chest pain at rest/before
exercise, other severe cardiac diseases (e.g. symptomatic aortic stenosis,
severe cardiac arrhythmias).
- Underweight (BMI<18,5 kg/m2).
- In case of smoking, unwillingness to stop smoking for at least the duration
of the study.
- Low e-health competencies (lowest proficiency according to Pharos quick
scan).
- Insufficient comprehension of Dutch language.
- Inability to be scheduled for therapy or meetings.
- Concurrent presence of other forms of joint disease than OA, RA or ACPA
positive arthralgia.
- Psychiatric disease.
- Total arthroplasty of hip or knee scheduled.
- No informed consent.
Design
Recruitment
Followed up by the following (possibly more current) registration
No registrations found.
Other (possibly less up-to-date) registrations in this register
In other registers
Register | ID |
---|---|
CCMO | NL66649.029.18 |
OMON | NL-OMON19881 |
OMON | NL-OMON21343 |
OMON | NL-OMON25088 |