Our primary objectives are to determine the diagnostic accuracy of handheld RCM in the diagnosing and subtyping of BCC in the head and neck compared to punch biopsy, and evaluate the associated rate of over- and understaging of BCC subtypes. In…
ID
Source
Brief title
Condition
- Skin neoplasms malignant and unspecified
Health condition
basal cell carcinoma, diagnostics, dermoscopy, confocal microscopy, rcm
Research involving
Sponsors and support
Intervention
- Medical device
Outcome measures
Primary outcome
1. The diagnostic accuracy of dermoscopy and HH-RCM in diagnosing and subtyping (Table 1) of BCC in the head and neck, compared to the current diagnostic reference standard (3mm punch biopsy).
2. Rate of over- and understaging of BCC subtypes in the head and neck by dermoscopy (index), HH-RCM (index), and punch biopsy (control) compared to the outcome of the final excisional specimen (reference standard).
Secondary outcome
1. Reliability of naked-eye examination in the diagnosing and subtyping of BCC in the head and neck.
2. Diagnostic value of established dermoscopic and RCM criteria in the differentiation of BCC subtypes in the head and neck.
3. Inter- and intraobserver agreement of the dermoscopic and HH-RCM criteria, diagnosis and subtyping of BCC.
Background summary
The increasing incidence of basal cell carcinoma (BCC) in the Netherlands has become a burden on healthcare system due to the associated costs in diagnosing, treatment, and follow-up of BCC patients. As the majority of BCCs requiring surgical treatment are localized in the head and neck, accurate presurgical subtyping is essential.The use of dermoscopy has been shown to significantly increase the accuracy of diagnosing BCCs, nevertheless, punch biopsy remains the reference standard due to the limited accuracy of BCC subtyping purely based on the clinical diagnosis. Even so, there is a substantial discordance between biopsy and excisional specimens where in 15% of the cases a more aggressive BCC subtype is found following excision. Reflectance confocal microscopy (RCM) is a noninvasive imaging technique that allows the in vivo visualization of cutaneous structures at a cellular-level, with an estimated sensitivity and specificity of 97% and 93% respectfully in diagnosing BCC. A handheld-RCM (HH-RCM) device (VivaScope®3000; CaliberID) was introduced allowing for more rapid evaluation and accessibility to the more concave areas in the head and neck (i.e. nose, periorbital and ears), while retaining comparable accuracy compared to conventional RCM. Several criteria were described positively correlating with the diagnosis of BCCs, however few studies have described criteria to differentiate between the different BCC subtypes. Our primary objectives are to: (1) To determine the diagnostic value of the addition of HH-RCM to dermoscopy in the management of BCC in the head and neck, defined by an significant increase in diagnostic accuracy in the diagnosing/subtyping of BCC. (2) Compare the diagnostic accuracy of dermoscopy and HH-RCM to the current diagnostic reference standard (punch biopsy).
Study objective
Our primary objectives are to determine the diagnostic accuracy of handheld RCM in the diagnosing and subtyping of BCC in the head and neck compared to punch biopsy, and evaluate the associated rate of over- and understaging of BCC subtypes. In addition, we will evaluate the reliability of naked-eye examination and the diagnostic significance of established dermoscopic and RCM criteria in the differentiation of BCC subtypes in the head and neck
Study design
This study was designed as a single-center, prospective, paired cross-sectional cohort study, conducted at the Netherlands Cancer Institute (NKI) (Amsterdam).
Intervention
Reflection confocal microscopy
Study burden and risks
"Participating subjects will not receive any clinical relevant delay in treatment or miss out of any standard of care and follow-up. There will be no additional visits to the outpatient clinic of Dermatology of the NKI compared to regular standard of care as study assessment will take place during the standard follow-up visits. Local side effects of routine invasive procedures in this study (punch biopsy and surgical excision) include erythema (often 1-2 weeks), pain (common 1 day), local swelling (often 1-3 days), abnormal scar formation (rare), hypo- and or hyperpigmentation (rare) and wound infection (rare). The RCM diagnostic procedure is non-invasive, painless and no side effects have been reported. There are no associated systemic side effects with any of the involved procedures. The burden due to study requirements is minimal. The RCM imaging will not interfere with the standard of care. "
Age
Inclusion criteria
1. Patients with suspected primary BCC on naked-eye examination as assessed by an experienced board-certified dermatologist.
2. Lesion localization in the head and neck (i.e. supraclavicular/above the 7th cervical vertebrae) with an indication for surgical treatment.
3. Anatomic localization of the lesion allows evaluation by HH-RCM and dermoscopy.
4. Patient age ¡Ý 18 years and is willing and able to comply with the study requirements and give written informed consent
Exclusion criteria
1. Recurrent BCC, defined as a suspected BCC localized within 5mm from the site of previously surgically or non-surgically treated BCC.
2. Suspected BCC localized outside the head and neck (i.e. infraclavicular/below the 7th cervical vertebrae).
3. Anatomical localization of lesion not accessible by HH-RCM or dermoscopic imaging.
4. Patients with genetic syndromes with increased risk of developing BCCs (e.g. Gorlin-Goltz, xeroderma pigmentosa).
5. Patients being treated by immunosuppressive medication.
6. Lesions on previously radiated skin.
7. Patients not eligible for surgical excision due to co-morbidity/ patient refusal.
Design
Recruitment
IPD sharing statement
Followed up by the following (possibly more current) registration
No registrations found.
Other (possibly less up-to-date) registrations in this register
No registrations found.
In other registers
Register | ID |
---|---|
NTR-new | NL6004 |
NTR-old | NTR6502 |
Other | Interne code : N17BCC |