Objectives1. Reduction of defect size after MMS with a pre-treatment with imiquimod 5% cream2. Reduction of tumour size of large nodular facial BCC, after pre-treatment with imiquimod 5% cream.3. Improvement of cosmetic results.4. Histological…
ID
Source
Brief title
Condition
- Skin neoplasms malignant and unspecified
Synonym
Research involving
Sponsors and support
Intervention
Outcome measures
Primary outcome
Defect sizes: Sizes are measured (in mm2), between group differences are
calculated.
Secondary outcome
Tumour sizes: Sizes are measured, between group differences are calculated
(imiquimod versus control group).
In addition sizes pre and post imiquimod treatment (in the imiquimod group)
will be compared.
Increase in area from baseline lesion to post-MMS defects are calculated and
compared between both groups.
Reconstruction time will be measered in both groups and the between group
difference will be noted.
Cost analysis:
Between group differences for total costs will be compared. These costs will be
related to decrease in defect size and cosmetic result.
Cosmetic outcome:
Outcomes of the visual analog scale will be compared for both groups.
Quality of life: A questionnaire will be used to compare both treatments.
Before treatment, 4 weeks and 3 months after treatment.
Background summary
Basal cell carcinoma (BCC) is the most common malignancy of the skin (1). While
the mortality rate due to this tumour is insignificant, an increasing group of
especially younger patients are concerned about the cosmetic outcome of the
treatment of a facial tumour. Various therapeutic modalities exist (1). In most
cases surgical excision will take place. Mohs micrographic surgery (MMS) is an
advanced technique, which is used mainly for BCC in the face and with high risk
for recurrence, in the H-zone or > 2 cm (2). The size of the defect after
excision of the tumour can significantly be reduced by using MMS, compared to
the standard surgical excision. The cosmetic outcome is therefore overall
better. In addition treatment of primary tumours does have a better cosmetic
outcome compared to recurrent tumours (3). MMS has the lowest recurrence rate
in the treatment of BCC (2). It is however, a time consuming and therefore
costs are higher (3).
New non-surgical treatments for BCC are investigated, such as imiquimod 5%
cream (imiquimod). Imiquimod is an immune respons modifier, it induces
cytokines which stimulate a cell-mediated immunerespons (4). Imiquimod 5% cream
has been demonstrated to be safe and effective in the treatment of anogenital
warts (5).
Studies show that imiquimod has a beneficial effect on small superficial and
small nodular BCCs, total or partial clearance is obtained (5-9).
Imiquimod could be used for BCC as an additional treatment before surgery, and
not only serve as a monotherapy. It could be an excellent pre-treatment for MMS
for larger nodular BCC. Pre-treatment with imiquimod 5% cream could reduce
tumour size and result in a smaller defect after MMS, and therefore result in a
better cosmetic outcome. Furthermore, it could reduce the number of Mohs rounds
needed to clear the tumour completely and therefore reduce the costs of this
treatment.
In other words; when imiquimod cream and MMS are combined, the chance on a
better outcome is increased. Imiquimod reduces tumour size and defect size. MMS
provides radicality, so that risk of recurrence is low. These factors all
provide a better cosmetic outcome. While BCC grows very slowly, a delay of 3
months between diagnosis and treatment is accepted.
Study objective
Objectives
1. Reduction of defect size after MMS with a pre-treatment with imiquimod 5%
cream
2. Reduction of tumour size of large nodular facial BCC, after pre-treatment
with imiquimod 5% cream.
3. Improvement of cosmetic results.
4. Histological evaluation of apoptosis by using caspase 3 and evaluation of
the upregulation of FasR to determine the sensitivity of the BCC for apoptosis.
5. Calculation of cost-effectiveness.
6. Comparing quality of life between groups.
7. Recurrence rates.
Study design
Study design:
Prospective randomised controlled study.
Treatment with imiquimod cream for 4 weeks. 6 Weeks after treatment MMS will be
performed.
The control group will only undergo MMS.
Follow-up 12 months.
The study will take place in The Catharina Hospital Eindhoven
Intervention
Product:
Imiquimod 5% cream (Aldara®) applied locally on the skin, on the target tumour
and 1 cm around the tumour. The cream has to be applied at night and left for
approximately 8 hours.
It has to be applied once daily, 5 days a week, for 4 weeks.
No other local treatment modality is allowed on the target area during the
study, in both groups.
Study burden and risks
Adverse events that have been reported are mainly mild local skin reactions;
these include erythema, itching, pain, erosions, and excoriations (5-7).
Multiple studies report less adverse events when using the lower frequency
dosing regimens (5-8,14,16). When reviewing literature, it appears that 87% of
the patients reports at least one local skin reaction, some patients need a
rest period if the local reactions are severe. 2% Of the patients stopped
treatment prematurely because of local skin reactions (17). In the trial
described by Schulze et al, 2 of 166 patients stopped therapy due to adverse
events. In one patient bleeding occurred in the treatment area and the other
patient develop a bacterial skin infection. It is not clear if the bleeding
occurred due to the treatment, BCC do bleed easily, spontaneously (16).
Systemic adverse events have been studied. No clinical or laboratory (blood and
urine) changes were observed (6,7,9). Subjective systemic adverse events were
mentioned in the study of Beutner et al, mainly fatigue, headache and fever.
Temperatures were measured and no fevers were noted (5).
In previous large controlled trials about imiquimod cream for anogenital warts,
no differences in frequency or severity of systemic adverse events were seen
between the imiquimod group and the placebo group (5).
Possible benefits: Reduction of tumour size, decrease of defect, improvement
cosmetic result.
Michelangelolaan 2
5602 ZA Eindhoven
NL
Michelangelolaan 2
5602 ZA Eindhoven
NL
Listed location countries
Age
Inclusion criteria
Patients > 18 yrs
Nodular/ nodular and partially superficial basal cell carcinoma in the face
Diameter 1-5 cm
Exclusion criteria
pregnant women
women who breastfeed
Recurrent BCC
BCC with agressive growth pattern
BCC within 1 cm from the eyes, lips or mucosa of the nose
Another skin cancer within 5 cm of the target tumor
Former treatment of BCC in the target area
Allergy for imiquimod cream or substances
Design
Recruitment
Medical products/devices used
Followed up by the following (possibly more current) registration
No registrations found.
Other (possibly less up-to-date) registrations in this register
No registrations found.
In other registers
Register | ID |
---|---|
EudraCT | EUCTR2007-000622-42-NL |
CCMO | NL16478.060.07 |