This study compares iMRI with cNN for the primary endpoint (percentage of residual tumor volume) and the secondary endpoints (complications, clinical functioning / quality of life, and survival).
ID
Source
Brief title
Condition
- Nervous system neoplasms malignant and unspecified NEC
- Nervous system neoplasms malignant and unspecified NEC
Synonym
Research involving
Sponsors and support
Intervention
Outcome measures
Primary outcome
For each treatment group the percentage of residual tumor as visible on the
postoperative scan will be compared to tumor volume on the preoperative scan.
The main question from the RACING-project is whether iMRI helps to achieve a
lower percentage of residual tumor volume compared to cNN.
Secondary outcome
* complications
* clinical performance (WHO Performance Scale) / quality of life
* survival
Background summary
Intraoperative MRI is a technical tool to perform more effective and safer
brain surgery. Current default treatment (conventional neuronavigation (cNN))
uses preoperative brain scans. During surgery several changes occur that cause
"brain shift", a displacement of the brain. As a consequence, preoperative
brain scans become inaccurate during surgery. iMRI can acquire a new scan
during a surgical procedure to correct for this accuracy caused by brain shift.
Until now only prospective and retrospective cohort studies have been
performed, but no randomized study to assess effectiveness and safety of iMRI
compared to cNN. Less residual tumor volume is associated with prolonged
survival. The hypothesis is that use of iMRI leads to less residual tumor than
the use of cNN.
Study objective
This study compares iMRI with cNN for the primary endpoint (percentage of
residual tumor volume) and the secondary endpoints (complications, clinical
functioning / quality of life, and survival).
Study design
A total of 54 patients with a brain tumor will be randomized in two treatment
groups: iMRI or cNN. Both groups will have a preoperative navigation scan made
within 72 hours before surgery. In both groups the neurosurgeon will operate
until he/she considers tumor resection to be maximal. In the cNN-group surgery
will be finished at that point. In the iMRI-group a new scan will be made after
administration of an intavenous contrast agent. If this shows contrast
enhancement that is interpreted by the neurosurgeon as being tumor tissue, this
will be resected if the neurosurgeon thinks this is justified. Then a new scan
will be made, and this "scan-resection-cycle" can be repeated until the
neurosurgeon considers the resection to be maximal. In the iMRI-group surgery
will be finished at that point. In both groups a new scan will be made within
48 hours after surgery. This will be used to measure postoperative tumor
volume. This will be compared to the preoperative tumor volume on the
preoperative navigation scan, to calculate the residual tumor volume.
Intervention
Randomization in the iMRI or cNN group, after which treatment will be given as
desribed in the summary paragraph "Study Design". Before and after surgery the
patient will be requested to fill in some questionnaires to address quality of
life. This will be done at admission, at discharge, and 3 months after surgery.
Study burden and risks
Like explained and supported by literature references in the research protocol,
there are risks related to performing brain surgery. There are no indications
that this risk would be increased in the iMRI-group compared to the cNN-group
(default treatment). Surgery time in the iMRI-group will be approximately 90
minutes longer compared to the cNN-group. The only burden that patients have is
the questionnaires that they will be requested to fill in for three times.
Postbus 5800
6202 AZ Maastricht
NL
Postbus 5800
6202 AZ Maastricht
NL
Listed location countries
Age
Inclusion criteria
* supratentorial brain tumor, on contrast enhanced dMRI suspected to be GBM
* indication for gross total resection (GTR) of the tumor
* age *18 years
* WHO Performance Scale * 2
* ASA class * 3
* adequate knowledge of the Dutch or French language
* informed consent
Exclusion criteria
- recurrent brain tumor
- multiple brain tumor localizations
- earlier skull radiotherapy
- earlier chemotherapy for GBM
- Chronic Kidney Disease or other renal function disorder
- known MR-contrast allergy
Design
Recruitment
Followed up by the following (possibly more current) registration
No registrations found.
Other (possibly less up-to-date) registrations in this register
No registrations found.
In other registers
Register | ID |
---|---|
ClinicalTrials.gov | NCT00943007 |
CCMO | NL25549.068.09 |