A lower hemoglobin concentration for red cell transfusion (restrictive transfusion strategy) will be non-inferior to a liberal strategy in terms of vital organ function (heart, brain and kidney) and mortality.
ID
Source
Brief title
Condition
- Cardiac therapeutic procedures
Synonym
Research involving
Sponsors and support
Intervention
Outcome measures
Primary outcome
The primary outcome is a composite score of any one of the following
events occurring during the index hospitalization (from the start of surgery
until hospital discharge or postoperative day 28, whichever comes first): (1)
all-cause mortality; (2) myocardial infarction; (3) new renal failure requiring
dialysis; and (4) new focal neurological deficit.
Secondary outcome
The secondary endpoints are as follows; see section 8.12 for definitions and
details: 1. Incidence of each individual component of the primary outcome:
in-hospital all-cause mortality, myocardial infarction, new renal failure
requiring dialysis, and new focal neurological deficit (index hospitalization)
2. Length of stay in the ICU and hospital (index hospitalization) 3. Prolonged
low output state defined as the need for two or more inotropes for 24 hours or
more, intra-aortic balloon pump postoperatively or ventricular assist device
(index hospitalization) 4. Duration of mechanical ventilation (index
hospitalization) 5. Infection; infection will be defined as septic shock with
positive blood cultures, pneumonia defined as roentgenographic infiltrate and
two of three criteria: fever, leukocytosis, and positive sputum culture, and/or
deep sternal or leg wound infection requiring intravenous antibiotics and/or
surgical debridement108 (index hospitalization) 6. Acute kidney injury (defined
by the Kidney Disease Improving Clinical Outcomes practice guideline,110)
(index hospitalization) 7. Gut infarction confirmed by imaging (e.g.
angiography), autopsy, or through surgical means (index hospitalization) 8. The
proportion of patients transfused and the number of blood products and
hemostatic products utilized (e.g. red cells, plasma, platelets,
cryoprecipitate, factor VII) (index hospitalization) 9. Death (within 6 months
of index surgery) 10. New onset dialysis (since incident surgery) status (6
months after index surgery) 11. Stroke (within 6 months of index surgery) 12.
Coronary revascularization (within 6 months of index surgery) 13. MI (within 6
months of index surgery) 14. Health Care Utilization (within 6 months of index
surgery) * Canadian data only
Background summary
Acute anemia is associated with increased mortality likely due to impaired
oxygen delivery and tissue hypoxia. Since hemoglobin contributes to more than
99% of blood oxygen content, severe anemia leads to inadequate tissue oxygen
delivery, resulting in tissue hypoxia, organ failure, and death. In acute
anemia the increase in mortality is proportional to the reduction in
hemoglobin. During cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB), the acute hemodilution that
occurs has been shown to reduce oxygenation in the brain, heart, kidney,
intestine, and muscle, although the critical hemoglobin concentration that
would lead to inadequate oxygen delivery during CPB has not been determined.
There are a number of complications related to transfusion that are associated
with considerable morbidity and mortality. Non-infectious risks from
transfusion such as TRALI, which tends to occur more frequently in patients
having cardiac surgery,has a high case fatality rate, 5 to 13%. Additionally,
administrative errors resulting in hemolytic transfusion reactions can be
life-threatening. Pulmonary edema, due to the volume of red cells transfused,
has also been shown to occur more frequently in patients with critical illness
and cardiovascular disease who were transfused at a hemoglobin concentration of
100 g/L compared to a hemoglobin concentration of 70 g/L. Although the risk of
acquiring the human immune deficiency virus and hepatitis C virus is low, new
emerging pathogens constantly threaten the blood supply. Unnecessary
transfusions also have an impact on the care of patients. Optimum utilization
of blood components is essential as there is a continuous strain on blood
systems because of increased blood utilization. Additionally, increased blood
utilization results in increased resource utilization and cost of blood is
increasing. In an era where there are new emerging pathogens and blood
shortages, it is essential that these patients be transfused appropriately.
There is a critical need to determine the appropriate threshold for red cell
transfusion in patients undergoing cardiac surgery. While restrictive
transfusion strategies have been shown to reduce transfusion in other patient
populations, it may be inappropriate and unsafe to extrapolate these findings
to cardiac surgery. This clinical uncertainty is reflected in the tremendous
inter-physician and inter-hospital variability in transfusion practice, which
are unrelated to patient risk factors. This has prompted the recommendation by
the expert panel of the NHLBI to classify a trial such as this as one of the
most important trials required. If our trial demonstrates the safety of a
restrictive strategy, the risks and costs attributable to unnecessary
transfusions will be reduced. Alternatively, if restrictive transfusion is
found to be inferior, risks of complications related to untreated perioperative
anemia will be reduced. Our multicentre international study will thus provide
high-quality generalizable data to guide transfusion practice worldwide,
regardless of its eventual results.
Study objective
A lower hemoglobin concentration for red cell transfusion (restrictive
transfusion strategy) will be non-inferior to a liberal strategy in terms of
vital organ function (heart, brain and kidney) and mortality.
Study design
An international, multi-centre, open-label, randomized controlled trial of two
commonly used transfusion strategies, using a non-inferiority trial design.
Intervention
Study participants will be randomized to one of the following transfusion
strategies in a 1:1 manner: * Restrictive transfusion strategy: patients will
receive a red cell transfusion if their hemoglobin is <75 g/L (<7.5 g/dL; <4.7
mmol/L) intraoperatively and/or postoperatively * Liberal transfusion strategy:
patients will receive a red cell transfusion if their hemoglobin concentration
is <95 g/L (<9.5 g/dL; <5.9 mmol/L) intraoperatively or postoperatively in the
intensive care unit; or <85 g/L (<8.5 g/dL; <5.3 mmol/L) on the ward. When the
appropriate hemoglobin trigger is reached, patients in each group will have one
unit of red cells administered at a time followed by repeat determination of
the hemoglobin concentration. Each group will be transfused only if their
hemoglobin concentration falls below the transfusion threshold.
Study burden and risks
It is an obligation of the site Investigator to obtain informed consent
from every study patient by means of a dated and signed informed consent form
before any study related procedure is performed. *Informed consent* also
implies individual discussion with the patient about the nature of study
interventions to be conducted in a language that is easy to comprehend, which
will take about 10 to 15 minutes. At 6 months, a telephone follow-up will occur
and the following clinical outcomes will be collected based on patient or
caregiver report, since hospital discharge/postoperative day 28: * Death (and
reason for death) * MI * Stroke * Surgical or non-surgical coronary
revascularization * New renal dialysis status at 6 months which will take about
5 to 10 minutes. risks: There are a number of complications related to
transfusion that are associated with considerable morbidity and mortality and
on the other hand acute anemia is associated with increased mortality.
30 Bond St, Toronto 30
Toronto ON M5B 1W8
CA
30 Bond St, Toronto 30
Toronto ON M5B 1W8
CA
Listed location countries
Age
Inclusion criteria
Age 18 or older
* Planned cardiac surgery using cardiopulmonary bypass
* Informed consent obtained
* Preoperative European System for Cardiac Operative Risk Evaluation (EuroSCORE I) of 6 or more (using the standard additive EuroSCORE I available at www.euroscore.org/calcold.html or refer to the study Manual of Operations)
Exclusion criteria
Age 18 or older * Planned cardiac surgery using cardiopulmonary bypass * Informed consent obtained * Preoperative European System for Cardiac Operative Risk Evaluation (EuroSCORE I) of 6 or more (using the standard additive EuroSCORE I available at www.euroscore.org/calcold.html or refer to the study Manual of Operations)
Design
Recruitment
Followed up by the following (possibly more current) registration
No registrations found.
Other (possibly less up-to-date) registrations in this register
No registrations found.
In other registers
Register | ID |
---|---|
ClinicalTrials.gov | NCT02042898 |
CCMO | NL55146.015.15 |